Writer: 470084 Write a personal thread (see attachment for more detailed instructions and lcture notes with other sources (if needed)): Class: Judicial Process Topic: Evidence Admission and Suppression ?Each state has adopted a variety of rules regarding what facts are deemed proper evidence. Only what a court deems admissible evidence may be considered in reaching a verdict of guilt or innocence. Evidence that is suppressed because it was gathered in violation of the Constitution may have a profound impact on the guilt of a defendant. However, the ability to limit what information a juror has access to is becoming increasingly more difficult to control. ?The prevalence of smartphones and tablets allows jurors to gather data about a defendant, victim, crime scene, or witness that was not authorized or even presented at trial or in fact was specifically prohibited by law to be used to determine guilt. But, the temptation to know “the truth” can drive jurors to ignore the mandates of the Constitution and the laws governing proper evidence. ?Thread: • If the goal for a trial is the search for justice, evaluate why there are rules that limit a juror’s access to information. • Should guilt or innocence only use information gathered in compliance with the Constitution and approved by the judge? • What happens if there are no rules? • Should there be exceptions, and if so, are exceptions still a decision in the hands of the judge or can individual jurors make up their own rules about what is useful information to decide guilt or punish? • Review the Grading Rubric. Be sure you provide the scriptural, constitutional, and scholarly basis for your positions. While ponding the answers to the questions above, be sure to consider the following: • Discuss biblical principles associated with evidentiary procedure. • Analyze the effect of the exclusionary rule on the operations of the courtroom workgroup. • Summarize how the decision in Miranda v. Arizona regulates the process of police interrogations of suspects. • Discuss the three major factors influencing plea bargaining and discretion. • Explain the opposing views regarding plea bargaining from the crime control and due process model perspectives.
Analyze the effect of the exclusionary rule on the operations of the courtroom workgroup